Nullification of Article 370: Kapil Sibal Calls For Brexit Like Referendum In Kashmir; Supreme Court Says There Is No Question of It
Speaking the language of the Pakistanis, Kapil Sibal calls for a referendum in Kashmir
Top court’s observation comes after Kapil Sibal, who represented some of petitioners against nullification of Article 370, referred to 2016 Brexit referendum in UK to emphasise the importance of people’s opinion in a democracy
“In a constitutional democracy, seeking the opinion of people has to be through established institutions,” says CJI.
Maintaining that democracy functions through institutions, the Supreme Court on Tuesday virtually rejected the idea of plebiscite in Jammu and Kashmir, saying there was no question of a Brexit-type referendum under the Indian Constitution.
“You can’t envisage a Brexit-type referendum. That’s a political decision which was taken by the then government. But within a constitution like ours, there is no question of a referendum,” a five-judge-Constitution Bench led by Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud told senior counsel Kapil Sibal, who represented some of the petitioners against nullification of Article 370 which gave special status to the erstwhile state of Jammu and Kashmir.
The top court’s observation came after Sibal referred to the 2016 Brexit referendum in the United Kingdom to emphasise the importance of people’s opinion in a democracy.
“Your lordships must remember Brexit. What happened? There was no constitutional provision (in the UK) seeking a referendum. But when you want to sever a relationship, you must seek the opinion of the people because people are central to the decision,” Sibal said.
However, the CJI said, “In a constitutional democracy, seeking the opinion of people has to be through established institutions. So long as democracy exists, any recourse of the will of the people has to be expressed by an established institution.”
As Sibal submitted that Parliament accorded approval to executive acts which unilaterally changed the Constitution as it was applicable to J&K,” the CJI said, “Once we presume that Parliament can (amend it), any amendment of Article 370 would be subject to criticism on the ground of morality, not (for want of) power.”
Sibal repeatedly termed the nullification of Article 370 as a “political act” bereft of constitutional authority.
“Can the Union of India in this manner terminate a relationship recognised in the Constitution of India?” he asked.
On the third day of hearing, the Bench frequently posed questions to Sibal on various aspects of the complex constitutional issues involving the provisions of the Constitution of India and the Constitution of Jammu and Kashmir.
The Bench sought to know if Article 370 — which was envisaged as a temporary provision—be converted into a permanent provision merely because the Constituent Assembly of the state ceased to exist.
“Was there an act required by the Indian Constitution – either in the form of a constitutional amendment or a parliamentary intervention to convert that into a permanent provision?” it asked.
To Sibal’s argument that Article 370 (3) which talked about making Article 370 inoperative, could not be acted upon in the absence of the Constituent Assembly of Jammu and Kashmir as envisaged under the proviso to Article 370(3), the CJI wondered of the proviso could swallow the main provision.
“You (Union of India) can change any provisions of the Constitution because you have a majority. This majoritarian culture cannot destroy the edifice of what our forefathers gave us. They cannot possibly justify it unless a new jurisprudence comes to light that they can do whatever they like as long as they have a majority,” Sibal submitted.
During the hearing, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said, “After 2019 exercise (nullification of Article 370) approximately 1,200 laws are now applicable to Jammu and Kashmir… All beneficial legislations available to other citizens now are available to J&K.”
@media only screen and (min-width: 480px){.stickyads_Mobile_Only{display:none}}@media only screen and (max-width: 480px){.stickyads_Mobile_Only{position:fixed;left:0;bottom:0;width:100%;text-align:center;z-index:999999;display:flex;justify-content:center;background-color:rgba(0,0,0,0.1)}}.stickyads_Mobile_Only .btn_Mobile_Only{position:absolute;top:10px;left:10px;transform:translate(-50%, -50%);-ms-transform:translate(-50%, -50%);background-color:#555;color:white;font-size:16px;border:none;cursor:pointer;border-radius:25px;text-align:center}.stickyads_Mobile_Only .btn_Mobile_Only:hover{background-color:red}.stickyads{display:none}
- SEO Powered Content & PR Distribution. Get Amplified Today.
- PlatoData.Network Vertical Generative Ai. Empower Yourself. Access Here.
- PlatoAiStream. Web3 Intelligence. Knowledge Amplified. Access Here.
- PlatoESG. Automotive / EVs, Carbon, CleanTech, Energy, Environment, Solar, Waste Management. Access Here.
- BlockOffsets. Modernizing Environmental Offset Ownership. Access Here.
- Source: https://www.indiandefensenews.in/2023/08/nullification-of-article-370-kapil.html
- :has
- :is
- :not
- 1
- 200
- 2016
- 2019
- a
- About
- Absolute
- Act
- acts
- After
- against
- All
- an
- and
- any
- applicable
- approval
- approximately
- ARE
- argument
- article
- AS
- asked
- aspects
- Assembly
- AUGUST
- authority
- available
- BE
- because
- beneficial
- border
- both
- Bottom
- Brexit
- but
- by
- Calls
- came
- CAN
- cannot
- Center
- central
- change
- changed
- chief
- Citizens
- clear
- color
- comes
- complex
- constituent
- Constitution
- convert
- converted
- could
- counsel
- Court
- criticism
- Culture
- day
- decision
- defence
- Democracy
- destroy
- Display
- do
- either
- established
- Ether (ETH)
- executive
- Exercise
- exist
- exists
- expressed
- fixed
- For
- form
- frequently
- functions
- gave
- General
- Government
- Ground
- happened
- Have
- he
- hearing
- HTML
- http
- HTTPS
- idea
- if
- importance
- in
- india
- Indian
- Institution
- institutions
- intervention
- into
- involving
- issues
- IT
- jpg
- Justice
- Kingdom
- Know
- language
- Laws
- Led
- left
- light
- like
- Long
- Main
- Majority
- Making
- manner
- max-width
- merely
- morality
- must
- name
- New
- next
- no
- None
- now
- of
- on
- only
- Opinion
- or
- Other
- our
- ours
- parliament
- Parliamentary
- People
- people’s
- permanent
- PHP
- plato
- Plato Data Intelligence
- PlatoData
- political
- possibly
- power
- previous
- provision
- question
- Questions
- recognised
- referendum
- referred
- relationship
- remember
- REPEATEDLY
- represented
- required
- Said
- saying
- says
- Screen
- Seek
- seeking
- senior
- So
- some
- sought
- special
- State
- Status
- subject
- submitted
- Supreme
- Supreme Court
- taken
- temporary
- that
- The
- The State
- the UK
- the United Kingdom
- then
- There.
- they
- Third
- this
- Through
- to
- top
- Transform
- true
- Tuesday
- Uk
- under
- union
- United
- United Kingdom
- upon
- us
- various
- virtually
- want
- was
- we
- What
- whatever
- when
- which
- white
- WHO
- will
- within
- would
- you
- z-index
- zephyrnet
More from Indian Defense News
Tech Mahindra, IBM Collaborate To Drive Digital Adoption
Source Node: 2524086
Time Stamp: Mar 23, 2024
Alpha Design Technologies Limited To Supply 400 Software-Defined Radios For Army Tanks
Source Node: 2184096
Time Stamp: Jul 25, 2023
India Will Enter Pak To Kill Terrorists Who Flee There: Defence Minister
Source Node: 2536918
Time Stamp: Apr 6, 2024
Is The Indian Navy Edging Closer To A Rafale Marine Order?
Source Node: 2031375
Time Stamp: Mar 25, 2023
‘An Attempt To Disrupt G20 Meet’: Army Thwarts Infiltration Bid In J&K’s Uri
Source Node: 2094169
Time Stamp: May 14, 2023
India Establishing Defence Wings In New Locations Around World: Army Chief Gen Pande
Source Node: 2365634
Time Stamp: Nov 4, 2023
Self-Reliance In Aircraft and Helicopter Engine Technology
Source Node: 2217849
Time Stamp: Aug 17, 2023
Indian Navy, Air Force Showing Interest In Indigenous Tapas Drones
Source Node: 2481212
Time Stamp: Feb 15, 2024
Some Steps Taken By Beijing Along India-China Border ‘Provocative’: Top White House Official
Source Node: 2043043
Time Stamp: Apr 1, 2023
Russia Supplying S-400 Air Defence Systems To India On Schedule – Defence Official
Source Node: 2212864
Time Stamp: Aug 14, 2023
DRDO To Set Up Remote Avalanche Warning System At Zoji La In Kashmir
Source Node: 2482851
Time Stamp: Feb 15, 2024